Tuesday, October 20, 2009

Pornoviolence.

There’s no getting around the fact that In Cold Blood has had vast amounts of praise heaped upon it since its release in ’66, but as with any work that stirs as much controversy as Capote’s seminal piece of literary journalism, it has also attracted its share of criticism and controversy.

Among those who leveled criticism at the novel was a fellow pioneer of the New Journalism movement (which subsequently led to literary journalism), Tom Wolfe. While Wolfe has certainly acknowledged the merits of what Capote achieved with In Cold Blood, he also raised some interesting points about its subject matter in one of his essays, entitled, Pornoviolence.

With Pornoviolence, Wolfe made a point of criticising the media for its habit of glorifying violence as a means of gratifying its audience, similarly to how pornography does with sex. In Cold Blood was among the texts to be criticised in the essay, with Wolfe writing: "The book is neither a who-done-it nor a will-they-be-caught, since the answers to both questions are known from the outset ... Instead, the book's suspense is based largely on a totally new idea in detective stories: the promise of gory details, and the withholding of them until the end."

Throughout my research into literary journalism I've read plenty about it being a style of writing that allows for a lot more description and detail than traditional news journalism does, but until now I haven't given much thought to when those details become gratuitous.

I'll admit that while I was reading In Cold Blood, even though I had a vague idea of what had happened to the Clutter family, I was eagerly waiting for Capote to lay out all the details. Has my predilection for slightly "edgier" entertainment conditioned me to react like that? I dunno. Wolfe's words have had me thinking about the issue though. At what point do the details of a violent crime become excessive in any form of journalism, literary or otherwise? The classic saying is, "if it bleeds, it leads," but where is the line drawn between respectable reporting and tasteless exploitation? I don't doubt that if you compared the coverage of a violent crime between a broadsheet and a tabloid you'd notice some stylistic differences.

Having given it some thought in the case of In Cold Blood, I don't think that the explicit details of how the Clutter family was slaughtered were in any way gratuitous, as they were a vital element of understanding Perry Smith and what he was capable of. Having said that, I do wonder if it was absolutely necessary, from a journalism perspective, to withhold the details of the crime for so long and continue to tease the audience as the story unfolded. Granted, it was an excellent narrative technique but when you consider it from the standpoint of journalistic necessity, Wolfe's argument is certainly not without credibility.

Given that my literary piece will focus on the lives of those are frequently confronted with horrific human injury, this does have me giving more consideration to how much detail I'll be using in describing the darker details.


Wednesday, October 7, 2009

A name forever tainted.

I've often wondered how it'd feel to be one of those people who has had such a detrimental effect on mankind that their very name is tainted with irreparable disgrace. I don't imagine it'd feel all too excellent. And I'm talking real, obscene, heinous disgrace here, the sort that would make most people very reluctant to bestow a similar name on their child. I mean, I don't imagine there are too many little Adolfs or Saddams or Osamas running around the schoolyard these days.

Then there are guys like Charles Ponzi, a guy who swindled and cheated and scammed people with gusto so steadfast that his surname has since become synonymous with dishonesty.

But what of the guys living just slightly in the shadows of guys like Ponzi? Men, who, despite being total scum on all accounts, manage to slip under the public radar on account of another guy being just that little bit worse than they are.

Such is the case of Marc Dreier, the subject of a recent Vanity Fair piece. In an age where money is often perceived as the one true God, you kind of get the feeling that the white collar criminals of Dreier's ilk have become our latter-day Antichrists.

But while so many news outlets are preoccupied with crucifying the likes of Marc Dreier and, the man who stole (among other things) his spot in the limelight, Bernie Maddoff, this article's author takes a somewhat more tasteful approach. Rather than portraying Dreier as some sort of inhuman greed incarnate, we're instead presented with a portrait of a man who had an absolutely unwavering determination to succeed. Burroughs specifically mentions Dreier's 50th birthday, a time that is a critical moment of reflection and assessment in the lives of many men. For Dreier, this day was a landmark in his meteoric rise to success and its ensuing collapse.

A desire to succeed is something that almost every man and woman in the world can relate to, but for Dreier it evolved from ambition to hubris. Of all the flaws in his character, this one was the most significant, being almost Shakespearean in magnitude. Still, the fact remains that in this detailed, thoroughly researched and well-written piece of literary journalism, Burrough has presented Dreier as a very human character and as a man that many of us can relate to on some level, whether we like it or not.

Perhaps most importantly, Burrough did not neglect to mention that with his residences around the world and hundreds of millions of dollars at his disposal, he could have run at any time. Instead, he stuck around to face what was coming to him. I'm quite sure how I'd describe that choice. I'm very hesitant to say that sticking around to face his punishment was admirable or honourable, because a man like Marc Dreier has forfeited any right he ever had to have those words associated with his name. 

Instead, I'm just going to say that it was the right thing to do, and leave it at that.

Tuesday, October 6, 2009

Through the looking glass.

While I haven't looked too extensively into the relationship between Truman Capote and Perry Smith I'm told that it went above and beyond the typical interactions of journalist and interviewee. Some say their relationship was only one of platonic friendship, others think that intimacy may have been involved. Either way, thinking about it has had me considering something over the past few days: At what point is the journalist in too deep?

I understand that your typical news journalist is meant to keep their distance from a story: Investigate, observe, report, move on. But in the course of reading the prescribed texts for this subject and exploring other material, it only becomes more apparent over time that literary journalism transcends what we typically expect of reporting the news.

In discussing a journalist's involvement with a story going from objective to subjective, I'm not really thinking about the Hunter S. Thompson style of deliberate immersion within the subject matter. Rather, I'm thinking about the times when a journalist is swept into the vortex of his or her story without ever intending to get to that point.

Recently I watched David Fincher's Zodiac again, the 2007 adaptation of Robert Graysmith's book of the same name. In typing that last sentence, I originally wrote "...of Robert Graysmith's novel or the same name," quickly deleted, unsure if novel was really the write word to use. Certainly it's an entertaining story, more entertaining than a lot of novels out there, but more than anything the book is an account the infamous unsolved murders in San Francisco that took place during the 1960s and 70s.

What I find most interesting about the story is that Graysmith, whose involvement with the case not only caused the end of his second marriage but also led to him receiving a handful of death threats, didn't start out as an investigative journalist at all. At the start of the Zodiac days, he was a newspaper cartoonist. How does a man go from that, to being in way too deep with a serial murderer investigation?

Just as Woodward and Bernstein's lives were in jeopardy during the Watergate scandal and just as Capote may have gotten closer than he should have to Perry Smith, Graysmith jeopardised his personal safety for the sake of a story. What does it mean when a journalist becomes a key element of the story they're investigating, particularly when that story has potentially dangerous implications for them? Is it really worth it? These men have been behind some of the most acclaimed pieces of literary journalism ever written, but does the end really justify the means?


Tuesday, September 29, 2009

Martin Scorsese can make anybody cooler.

Whenever word gets out that a film adaptation is being planned for a book the response is usually something to the tune of, "time for Hollywood to ruin another book." While it's true that there have been some heinously godawful book-to-movie adaptations over the years I don't think it's fair to label Hollywood as the ruiner of all things good from the realm of literature. Let's face it, occasionally a filmmaker will put together an adaptation of a book that ends up being so good it borders on perfect.

But I'm  not talking about the time that filmmaker from New Zealand directed that little hobbits and elves trilogy that generated the tiniest amount of buzz when it was released earlier this decade. Not that those movies weren't decent or anything, it's just that they don't have a whole lot to do with journalism - although I'm sure you could find somebody who'd argue that they do.

No, in this case I'm talking about a book called Wiseguy written in the mid 80s by New York crime journalist Nicolas Pileggi. In 1990 this Hollywood guy called Martin Scorsese came along and had the nerve to adapt it into one of the most spectacularly entertaining movies of all time.

Like Francis Ford Coppola had done before him with The Godfather, Scorsese had taken this story of life in the New York mafia and given it a perfect cinematic representation. In the case of both films they represent an almost sublime synergy of direction, performances, cinematography, editing and music. Where they differ though, is in their realism and tone. The Godfather is far more theatrical and operatic whereas Goodfellas is far more lifelike and more akin to a punk rock record.

But one thing I've had on my mind since watching Goodfellas again last week is whether or not Scorsese's vision of Pileggi's book distorts the images of the people Pileggi was originally trying to portray. While Scorsese's direction hasn't exactly painted the characters as honorable or misunderstood, the sheer density of cinematic cool he's injected into the film through its cinematography, editing and soundtrack has given the criminals something of a rockstar quality.

In one scene for instance, you've got Robert DeNiro silently plotting the murder of another character while the camera slowly pushes in on his face and Cream's Sunshine of Your Love plays over the top of the scene. It's one of the many examples of this cool mood and atmosphere that Pileggi wouldn't have been able to create in the book.

So again, although Scorsese isn't exactly aggrandising these characters, he has, to an extent, given them more charm than they might have had in the pages of Pileggi's text. Which makes me wonder what sort of implications this has (if any) from a journalistic perspective. After all, Pileggi's Wiseguy remains a highly acclaimed piece of literary journalism, but how does its film adaptation compare to say, the 1967 film of In Cold Blood starring Robert Blake? A film that, by all accounts, was far less stylised than Goodfellas and far more reflective of its source material.

Granted, the film industry is all about entertainment and it's a filmmaker's responsibility to use all of the tools in his repertoire to the best of his ability in order to, hopefully, create the best film he can. Scorsese did that with Goodfellas. But what sort of responsibilities does Hollywood have when it comes to adapting books that were based on true events? At what point does a filmmaker risk making martyrs out of murderers?


Sunday, September 20, 2009

Nothing like a good segue.

I'd already planned to do two posts today, but I hadn't planned for it to start this way. I'm going to be writing about Bret Easton Ellis' debut novel, Less Than Zero. Having read all of his published words, I feel it's his best work alongside American Psycho. Anyway, on the back cover of my copy of Less Than Zero there's a quote from somebody named Emily Prager.

I've no idea who Emily is, but she says:

"With spare, seamless writing he tells us a tale of collegiate Christmas in LA that makes Jack Kerouac and his beat generation seem like pussies."

Considering I'd just gotten through writing about Kerouac and the supposedly seminal On The Road, I felt like this was a nice way to tie the two posts together. And now, with nothing else to say, comes a ham-handed segue into my next paragraph.

One of the many things that struck me about Less Than Zero the first time I read it was how pared to the bone Ellis' writing was. A lot like Bukowski, he didn't waste much time by using too many adjectives. The language was sharp, direct and almost apathetic, which seems appropriate given the book's overall feel of nihilism. Adjectives are best left at the disposal of romantics like Fitzgerald.

But while Less Than Zero doesn't really qualify as journalism per sé, its language style is somewhat reflective of how journalists are taught to write. So for that reason I found itsort of  relevant to this whole literary journalism caper. I guess in literature if you're not writing as a journalist you can still write like a journalist.

I'll check in again once I'm through with On The Road.

I remember reading an interview with Hunter S. Thompson once, who said he didn't care for it. He described as "overly sentimental romantic bullshit," or words to that effect.

Terrific.

Saturday, September 19, 2009

"On The Road" again.

I'm sure this happens to everybody. People are talking about movies or books or TV shows or music or whatever, and something comes up that everybody in the group is familiar with. Everybody but yourself, that is. When it becomes apparent to the rest of the group that you've never had the purported privilege of experiencing whatever it is they're raving about, the following conversation usually takes place:

"Oh my god, seriously? You haven't seen it?"
"Yeah, never got around to watching it."
"How?"
"I dunno, just didn't."
"Oh dude, you HAVE to see it. Next time you go to the video shop, get it."
"I don't go to video shops anymore."
"Okay, well download it or whatever."
"Will do."
"Actually, better still. I've got it on DVD, I'll let you borrow it."
"No, that's okay, thanks though."
"No it's no problem. I'll bring it over next time I'm at your place."
"Cool, thanks."

Nine times out of ten the endorser will forget to lend you the DVD, which is great, because then it saves you the trouble of leaving it on your coffee table for 3 months before finally giving it back without ever watching it. Maybe that's just me.

Anyway, there are three works of creative fiction that I've never got around to experiencing, but ALWAYS come up in conversation in my life.

They are: The Princess Bride, Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom, and Jack Kerouac's On The Road.

Fans of the first two find the fact that I've never seen them the most troubling, seeing as I spent 4 years working in a video shop, but it's the literati crowd who can't come to terms with the idea that there are people who haven't read Kerouac's book.

Yes, I get it, he's an important literary figure.
Yes, I get it, he influenced generations of writers that followed him.
Yes, I get it, On The Road is meant to be a genre-changing piece of work.

 I have no real excuse for not reading it until now, other than not particularly giving a shit. But now it's become relevant to my life once again,  this time as a required text for not one, but two Uni subjects. So I guess I'm out of excuses.

I'll post another entry once I'm done with it. Maybe I'll love it, maybe I'll hate it. Maybe it'll change my life's direction, maybe I'll forget it after closing the back cover. Who knows? What I do know is that after this, I think I'll be done with stories of troubled young men in early 20th century America for a while.

Having recently re-read Catcher in the Rye, Junky, The Great Gatsby and now On The Road, I feel like I'm about due for something more contemporary.

Thursday, September 3, 2009

Not quite fact, but not quite fiction either.

Be forewarned that as I write this I'm operating on a bunch of cold and flu meds while in the throes of a mad fever and a handful full of other unpleasant bodily malfunctions, so, apologies if my thought patterns seem a bit out of order. Thing is, I had this idea for a blog post and if I don't get it out now, I'll keep putting it off until a later date. And I know that making hilariously original jokes about procrastination is how all Uni students fill in about 86% of their spare time, but yeah, I need to get this done. 

Here goes...

Recently I spent a couple of days reading The Great Gatsby again, a book that everybody in the world has read and everybody in the world worth knowing enjoys. Well maybe that's not quite accurate, but it seemed like a cool statement nonetheless.


Anyway, I refuse to drone on about the book's themes of romance and nostalgia and personal identity and all that because, by this point, what can be said about Gatsby that hasn't been said already? I suppose you could say that the scene where Nick and Daisy are chased down a canal in a speedboat by an Apache gunship is poorly written, but the statement wouldn't have much credibility. When criticising literature it's best to make comments that are actually true of the book. And that scene was awesome.

What I do want to talk about in this post though is the book's geographical and historical setting; Upper-class America in the 1920s. 'The Jazz Age,' as Fitzgerald himself put it. Among the myriad accolades heaped upon this book, one thing Fitzgerald is often credited for is crafting an incredibly accurate portrait of the lifestyles of the wealthy at that time and place in history. Just as John Kennedy Toole is credited with painting the most accurate literary portrait of New Orleans in A Confederacy of Dunces, which is kind of a shame, seeing as that portrait is nestled in the pages of the most infuriatingly bad book I've ever forced myself to finish reading.

But while both authors have written narratives that are fictitious (more or less), the setting of both books and the idiosyncrasies of the characters who inhabit those settings both ring very true to life. Which got me thinking that sometimes, if written well enough, a work of narrative fiction could be more accurate in portraying society and reality than a traditional piece of news journalism. When an article demands a lead of 25 - 30 words there's no room for those little details that are often so prevalent in fiction and, as I keep discovering, literary journalism.

That's it.

But finally, just because I'm feeling sentimental:

Gatsby believed in the green light, the orgiastic future that year by year recedes before us. It eluded us then, but that's no matter--tomorrow we will run faster, stretch out our arms farther.... And one fine morning-- So we beat on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past